- Oxley
- Oyler
- Pacha
- Pacheco
- Pacifico
- Pacione
- Padzunas
- Paga
- Colomba
- Cosimo Maria Born: December 31, 1850
- Costanza Maria Born: March 17, 1848
- Federico
- Federico Born: 1776, Died: January 11, 1841
- Federico Maria Born: August 4, 1841
- Felice
- Giovanna Born: November 10, 1860
- Giovanna Maria Born: February 15, 1844
- Giovanna Maria Born: October 4, 1853
- Giovanni Died: March 31, 1813
- Giovanni Maria Born: March 22, 1814
- Girolamo Born: 1779, Died: August 4, 1836
- Libera Born: 1754, Died: July 1, 1818
- Orazia Born: 1800, Died: February 28, 1840
- Paolina Carmina Maria Born: July 15, 1809
- Paolina Maria Born: July 4, 1822, Died: August 13, 1843
- Rosa
- Rosa Maria Born: February 15, 1857
- Selestica Maria Born: 1801
- Pagie
- Pagliaro
- Painter
- Nicolas Born: 1624, Died: December 1684
- Ursula Born: 1643, Died: December 12, 1700
- Pairinsi
- Paladino
- Palermio
- Palmer
- Palmieri
- Palmisano
- Palmquist
- Palombino
- Palumbo
- Pannell
- Panno
- Pannullo
- Pantermehl
- Paolillo
- Pape
- Papi (Pope)
- Alda Elizabeth Marie Born: March 30, 1918, Died: March 12, 2005
- Anita Teresa Born: 1920
- Anna Born: February 11, 1882
- Antonio
- Antonio Born: July 2, 1888
- Ardella Christina Born: November 22, 1913, Died: March 16, 2005
- Armenia Elizabeth Born: April 6, 1915, Died: March 8, 1989
- Beatrice Born: May 23, 1910, Died: May 13, 1997
- Bertha Born: 1921
- Bonifacio Born: 1866, Died: July 4, 1867
- Bonifacio Born: May 8, 1879, Died: November 23, 1921
- Cesidio Born: 1850, Died: December 1, 1912
- Domenica Anna Born: February 2, 1909, Died: September 21, 1993
- Doretta "Dorothy" Born: June 5, 1916, Died: August 20, 2003
- Enrico "Henry" Born: January 18, 1896
- Maria Born: November 26, 1885, Died: October 3, 1887
- Maria Born: December 1, 1907, Died: November 15, 2001
- Raffaele Born: September 17, 1877
- Papia
- Pappolardo
- Paradiso
- Paragano
- Parish
- Sarah Born: 1852, Died: 1941
- Parisi
- Park
- Isabel Born: November 2, 1628, Died: March 31, 1665
- Parker
- Parkhurst
- Elizabeth Born: May 18, 1628, Died: April 4, 1657
- Parkinson
- Parks
- Jane Born: January 1, 1839, Died: October 1, 1924
- Robert
- Parlatti
- Parrella
- Parucci
- Pasqua
- Pasquantonio
- Passante
- Passumato
- Pasta
- Pastore
- Pate
- Paternosso
- Path
- Patitucci
- Patrono
- Patti
- Patty
- Aaron Born: 1849
- Charles C. Born: August 1815, Died: September 14, 1864
- Charles E. Born: October 6, 1877, Died: February 9, 1936
- Edward Alonzo Born: February 1854, Died: February 20, 1910
- Edward Alonzo Born: August 9, 1904, Died: July 1, 1963
- Eliza Belle Born: 1859, Died: 1913
- Eunice Viola Born: September 1861, Died: March 1929
- Josephine Alice Born: September 3, 1881, Died: January 16, 1961
- Malissa Born: 1854, Died: 1879
- Nancy Born: 1856
- Theodosia Dolores Born: September 21, 1864, Died: April 29, 1919
- Paul
- Albert
- Dennis
- Duane
- Earl
- Elenora Born: 1900, Died: 1994
- Emil
- Emil, Jr.
- Florence
- Henry Born: 1857, Died: 1907
- Herbert C. Born: 1897
- Ida Marie Born: August 8, 1888, Died: November 19, 1958
- Janet
- Kenneth Died: 1966
- Kevin
- Marilyn
- Michael
- Oscar Johnson Born: September 24, 1876, Died: July 25, 1944
- Pamela
- Richard
- Robert A. Born: 1901
- Smiley H. Born: 1848, Died: 1915
- Paulus
- Paura
- Pauri
- Paviglianti
- Payne
- Clarence Otto Born: September 15, 1882, Died: November 12, 1976
- Edith Ellen Born: September 4, 1912, Died: September 17, 1923
- George Born: December 29, 1849, Died: December 25, 1895
- John Born: 1852, Died: 1893
- Luella Born: 1877, Died: 1958
- Virgil Eugene Born: December 5, 1906, Died: October 7, 1909
- Payton
- Peacock
- Pearson
- Pease
- Abigail Born: August 2, 1700, Died: March 4, 1739
- Bathsheba Born: 1684, Died: June 1725
- Deborah Born: 1703
- Hannah Born: August 6, 1690, Died: August 17, 1767
- Issac Born: 1709
- James Born: March 15, 1627, Died: March 27, 1719
- James Born: 1664, Died: 1711
- Jeremiah Born: 1707, Died: October 10, 1729
- Jeremiah Born: 1729, Died: July 3, 1749
- John Born: November 1608, Died: 1677
- John Born: 1666, Died: March 16, 1699
- Jonathan Born: 1710, Died: January 1778
- Martha Born: 1682, Died: October 31, 1716
- Martha Born: January 12, 1696, Died: November 30, 1774
- Mary Born: 1680, Died: 1746
- Matthew Born: 1675, Died: 1718
- Mehitable Born: 1685, Died: October 31, 1716
- Nathaniel Born: December 28, 1677, Died: February 1752
- Nathaniel Born: 1710, Died: August 17, 1767
- Persis Born: 1734, Died: April 12, 1795
- Samuel Born: 1703, Died: September 20, 1789
- Sarah Born: April 2, 1699
- Stephen Born: 1670, Died: 1728
- Stephen Born: 1717, Died: January 28, 1784
- Theophilus Born: 1705, Died: 1783