- Colyer
- Benajah (B. 26 Oct 1805, D. 31 Oct 1881)
- Benajah (B. 1861, D. 6 Dec 1892)
- Benjamin F. (B. 1873)
- Charles Henry (B. 1859)
- Charlotte (B. 10 Oct 1843, D. 10 Oct 1843)
- Diadama (B. 24 Jun 1853, D. 13 Jul 1939)
- Dollie Maude (B. 1 Dec 1869, D. 5 Sep 1954)
- Edward (B. May 1893)
- Elizabeth (B. 18 Jan 1840)
- Florence M. (B. Feb 1880)
- Francis Marion (B. 6 Feb 1851, D. 15 May 1933)
- Ichabod (B. 21 Nov 1844, D. 16 Dec 1925)
- James (B. 1833, D. 1834)
- Jeremiah W. (B. 1871)
- John
- Jonathan (B. 11 Jul 1865)
- Loretta M. (B. 1870)
- Marian (B. 1866)
- Martha J. (B. 1862)
- Mary M. (B. 1831, D. 1925)
- Maud (B. Oct 1886)
- Minnie (B. Oct 1886)
- Nancy June (B. 25 Aug 1855, D. 29 Oct 1925)
- Nellie (B. Jun 1882)
- Orange Lemon (B. 27 Feb 1847, D. 27 Aug 1849)
- Reuben W. (B. 1878)
- Robert B. (B. 1860)
- Silas (B. 11 Jul 1865)
- Thomas A. (B. 1864)
- Thomas Jefferson (B. 14 Jan 1842, D. 14 Oct 1928)
- Twin Brother (B. 1833)
- William (B. 15 May 1836, D. 11 Dec 1915)
- William A. (B. 1869)
- Conaway
- Conder
- Condit
- Connataro
- Connor
- Connoyer
- Anna (B. Aug 1896, D. 1988)
- Bertha Cecile (B. 3 May 1899, D. 16 Jun 1993)
- Claudine (B. Jul 1885, D. 1955)
- Corrine M. (B. Feb 1888, D. 1933)
- Edgar Bernard (B. Sep 1894, D. 1966)
- Elmer L. (B. 1902, D. 1960)
- John Baptist (B. Jun 1891, D. 1979)
- Joseph (B. Feb 1860, D. 1921)
- Maggie (B. Jun 1889)
- Oliver (B. Mar 1886)
- Ralph A. (B. 1906, D. 1968)
- Vincent Julius (B. 1908, D. 1981)
- Conrad
- Consolazio
- Constable
- Constantino
- Contasti
- Conte
- Contente
- Contosi
- Cookson
- Coolbaugh
- Coons
- Cooper
- Copen
- Coppage
- Coravetta
- Corbett
- Cordery
- Cordum
- Coretto
- Corey
- Cornish
- Corrado
- Agapito Antonio (B. 6 Nov 1829, D. 7 Sep 1830)
- Anna Luisa (B. 26 Aug 1822, D. 7 Jul 1904)
- Anna Rosaria (B. 4 Oct 1812, D. 12 Mar 1889)
- Antonio Rocco (B. 23 Dec 1856, D. 29 Jul 1930)
- Domenica Rosa (B. 22 Nov 1818, D. 14 Jul 1890)
- Donato Antonio (B. 24 Jan 1817, D. 2 Sep 1817)
- Giovanni (B. 10 Oct 1864, D. 10 Dec 1943)
- Giovanni Battista (B. 1789, D. 11 Apr 1864)
- Giuseppa
- Maria Rosaria (B. 31 Mar 1854, D. 18 Oct 1855)
- Maria Rosaria (B. 1861)
- Marta Rosa (B. 11 Mar 1821, D. 6 Aug 1821)
- Pangrazio (B. 24 Feb 1825, D. 6 Jan 1826)
- Pangrazio (B. 30 Jan 1827, D. 6 Feb 1905)
- Corritelli
- Corvella
- Corvetta
- Cosagra
- Costa
- Costabile
- Costantino
- Costanza
- Costanzo
- Costello
- Cota
- Cotroneo
- Cotter
- Cotterall
- Elizabeth (B. 16 Dec 1844, D. 6 Dec 1914)
- George W (B. 9 Jul 1849)
- Isabel (B. 28 Nov 1830, D. 1871)
- John (B. 25 Sep 1802, D. 5 Jan 1865)
- John, II (B. 29 Nov 1832, D. 22 Mar 1923)
- Jonas (B. 9 Jan 1839, D. 29 Dec 1923)
- Martha A Nettie (B. 17 Jan 1847, D. 27 Mar 1910)
- Mary Ann (B. 1 Jan 1834, D. 9 Sep 1881)
- Permelia (B. 16 Jul 1836, D. 12 Oct 1886)
- William (B. 1751, D. 1805)
- Cottone
- Cotugno
- Cousins
- Cowan
- Cowley
- Cox
- Coyle
- Cozzilli
- Cozzillo
- Crabtree
- Crafa